Stagflation leading to Recession - The Kodiak Bear Thesis

I suspect this Wharton professor will also be surprised when people die in a ford that is, on average, 6 inches deep.

One of the major reasons for the recent productivity drop has been that the sectors with lower productivity - such as leisure and hospitality - were the slowest to bounce back.

image
(Source)

We see another view of this in the productivity data itself:


(Source)

We can see that jump in productivity right after COVID time. We innovated well in response to the crisis and managed to actually keep productivity up despite all the issues.

Also, a counterfactual - why would businesses hire if there was a lowering in productivity, and therefore profits? Because they choose to satisfy the additional demand that leads to higher absolute profits, even though the marginal productivity of the additional unit of labor is lower, leading to potentially lower profit as a % of revenue.

In sum, I think we’re simply seeing a process of mean reversion happening in terms of productivity.

Btw another confounding factor is GDP is composed of a couple of things: consumption, investments, (exports - imports) and government spending. Some went up, and some went down. And each has a different impact of productivity. From the BEA:

The decrease in real GDP reflected decreases in private inventory investment, residential fixed investment, federal government spending, and state and local government spending, that were partly offset by increases in exports and consumer spending. Imports, which are a subtraction in the calculation of GDP, increased (table 2).

The decrease in private inventory investment was led by a decrease in retail trade (mainly “other” general merchandise stores). The decrease in residential fixed investment was led by a decrease in “other” structures (specifically real estate brokers’ commissions). The decrease in federal government spending reflected a decrease in nondefense spending that was partly offset by an increase in defense spending. The decrease in nondefense spending reflected the sale of crude oil from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, which results in a corresponding decrease in consumption expenditures. Because the oil sold by the government enters private inventories, there is no direct net effect on GDP. The decrease in state and local government spending was led by a decrease in investment in structures. The increase in imports reflected an increase in services (led by travel).

The increase in exports reflected increases in both goods (led by industrial supplies and materials) and services (led by travel). The increase in consumer spending reflected an increase in services (led by food services and accommodations as well as “other” services) that was partly offset by a decrease in goods (led by food and beverages).


(Source)

Final thought - we are entering a period of economic slowdown, which means we’ll probably shed some of these employment gains in the coming quarter or three. I wonder if Prof. Siegel will celebrate our productivity gains then as a Pyrrhic victory, as lower productivity workers get the boot.

(@Brutus would you share the actual article please - maybe I missed something erudite that actually makes the case that this productivity collapse is of “unheard proportions,” and is “significant”.)

3 Likes

Yes, it’s here

2 Likes

Copying this take on JPow’s speech today from TF courtesy of @TheHouse

This is why I thought the speech this morning was bearish. Cutting through his spin. J Pow in my opinion was more hawkish and realistic than I have heard him this year. Before heading into the speech, we have seen for the last 6-8 weeks or so an opinion primarily in equities that inflation has peaked and J Pow would recognize that the economy is slowing and start an accommodating cycle. This comes from the fact that this is what the fed has done every single time the economy has slowed in the last 10 years. This morning he recognized that the economy is slowing (something we already know) but then said that they would continue to tighten into that slowing economy. Actually quoted Volker in his reasoning. So when thinking about equities, what does this mean? It means that the fed is serious about fighting inflation, they don’t want it to be persistent or runaway like the 70’s. So essentially, the fed pivot will not be coming. Companies in the US are already seeing changes in their balance sheet and a continued hiking cycle means this wont get easier anytime soon. Along with that, the expansion of credit or credit impulse will continue to tighten, this is a mechanical fact. Put simply, this means less demand through credit creation. So the market started pricing in that reality today. Hope this helps.

He’s much smarter than I on these topics so I won’t really add much besides saying that we need to think about how much of this is already known and priced in. Obviously something took the market by surprise here and we’re watching that thing be priced in at this moment, but realistically how off guard were the markets caught? We’ll see I suppose.

4 Likes

So earlier in the week it seemed like the market was pricing things according. Things were fairly bearish and all the talk shows were saying that JPow was going to stay hawkish but bring the market back to reality. Then on Wednesday/Thursday we had a few companies give good earnings and the market appeared to completely ignore what was said earlier in the week and somehow started thinking that rate reductions we’re going to start. So instead of 75bps it started think 50bps. It then started an irrational run when Biden started talking about student loan forgiveness which is bearish for the market but it went vertical anyway. Next earnings cycle should be interesting and October’s lead up to Fed rate hikes are also going to be interesting considering that September is normally bearish. I’m still overall bearish and leaning short term bearish as well at least until end of September. Then maybe the market will have dipped enought to reverse into earnings and then start it’s finally fall when earnings are less than expected. Just my thoughts on what we’ve been seeing.

3 Likes

Market caught off guard because market expected 2 rate cuts in 2023.

Fed said no rate cuts

Market said rate cut

JPow said no rate cuts

Market said “oh ok then”

1 Like

It’s interesting because the bond market does not seem to be pricing it in. The 1Y is up 1.8 bps and the 2Y is up 2.9bps only.

image

Also not showing up in the change of probabilities for mid-next year:

The obvious explanation is bond market knew already and priced this non-cut in, it’s the equity market that has just started to catch up. Less likely is that equities are over reacting, and this sell-off is overdone.

3 Likes

Closed 90% of my puts here.
Had multiple strikes hit 250%+

Full port on the day
Screenshot_20220826-134205_Webull

Heading into the mountians here in a few hours, will be back in Valhalla on Sunday.
Hope everyone has a great weekend.

5 Likes

Also big shout out to @Kevin, even I didnt believe J Pow would go that hawkish today. He called the Jackson Hole catalyst 100% accurate over a week ago.

Cheers dude

2 Likes

Yeah bond markets seemed to be pricing in the true state of the fed, at least more than the stock market. Couple days ago I mentioned that stock markets should not be this high since the DXY was at ATH and the 2 year yield was high of the year. I think this is the stock market doing some catch-up.

2 Likes

So, after rewatching J Pow’s speech at Jackson Hole and also reading the transcript carefully. It seems that the market is finally believing that the fed is going to keep raising rates, and hold them there until inflation comes back down to around 2%.

Let’s examine some data…

SPY for 2022 with CPI data, FOMC meetings (rate hike day), and FOMC Minutes dates:

Sorry for all the horizontal lines, those are my support/resistance and I didn’t want to delete them.

Now let’s take a look at CPI, keep in mind the time lag (July data is released in August):

Also here is CORE inflation for reference:

Let’s start with the blue line on 3/10 which was CPI data for February. Inflation has been creeping up and is now at 7.9% (Core 6.4%), the fed realizing this is not transitory. A few days later, the purple line on 3/16 was the Fed meeting where they hiked the rate a modest 25bps (discount rate now at 50bps, the first increase since they slashed the rates back in march 2020 cuz of COVID). The market thinks this isn’t bad, a little rate increase and all will return to normal eventually, let’s fucking RIP!

4/6 on the red line is the FOMC minutes, the market likely finally got the first glance that the fed was starting to show concern about high inflation, but no big deal yet, everything will be okay.

The comes the blue line on 4/12 with the next CPI release for March data. It came in at 8.5%, up 0.6% from previous month (Core 6.5%, up 0.1%). Market held for a couple days then was like “oh shit this is bad inflation is still going up” and started a downtrend.

Now the purple line on 5/4 was the next Fed rate hike, a whopping 50bps, biggest single rate hike since May 2000! J Pow means business and the market spiked that day, then was like, WTF raising rates is bad for stonks, and dumped the next day and started a downtrend to the next CPI data.

Now on 5/11 we had April’s CPI data of 8.3% (Core 6.2%)… could inflation have peaked? Maybe? Just maybe? Market becomes cautiously optimistic trading sideways until…

5/25 red line is FOMC minutes, and apparently the market took whatever was in there thinking things weren’t that bad, maybe inflation did peak, so the market went up a little, then started to trade sideways.

Next CPI was the blue line on 6/10, the market pulled back a couple days before, likely de-risking just incase inflation didn’t peak. So the May data showed 8.6%, or an increase of 0.3% from previous month, and a new high. But Core inflation dropped to 6.0%! Gas and food prices have been skyrocketing with no end in sight! Uh oh, fear and panic, this is BAD! Market shits itself hard!

A week later on 6/15 we have the purple line with the FOMC rate hike, a new whopper of 75bps! Now the biggest single rate hike since 1994!!! J Pow means business and they are gonna nip things in the bud! The market was happy that day and went green. But then the next couple days it tanked… oh yeah these rate hikes are bad for business! Market bottoms at 362.17 (OUCH!)

Now over the weekend the market got to thinking, maybe this last 75bps (for a total discount rate of 1.75%) is a good thing, it’s gonna fight inflation bringing prices down and stonks gonna go up! Gas prices finally peaked back on 6/14, and diesel on 6/19. Maybe things finally topped out? So the market started a slow climb with a lot of volatile dates of uncertainty.

So now we are at 7/6 with the red line for FOMC minutes. Seems that J Pow has got it under control, let’s just chill and see what next CPI data is like in a few days.

7/13 is next CPI data for June. ARE YOU KIDDING IT’S 9.1%?!?!?! Core did manage to decrease another 0.1% to 5.9%, so there’s that. Oh don’t worry, Pappa Biden says this is all just temporary due to “Putin’s Price Hike” and he’s doing all he can to bring down gas & food prices post haste! Don’t worry, it’s all transitory, just ignore gas & food, CORE inflation went down!!! Market believes what Biden is shoveling, and says stonks only go up!

Now on 7/27 the purple line is the next FOMC meeting. Another 75bps banger! We are now at a discount rate of 2.50%. Unanimous vote, the Fed means business! J Pow and crew feel confident they can get inflation under control, gas prices have been dropping from the mid-June peak, food prices are still up there though. Market thinks the worst is behind, and continues on its roaring comeback! RISE! RISE! RISE!

8/10 comes rolling around with the blue line showing July CPI data. Everyone is expecting good numbers, cuz after all gas has been going down, right? HALLELUJAH it dropped to 8.5%, but oh wait Core is being stubborn still at 5.9%. Biden says, “FORGET ALL THOSE SILLY NUMBERS, ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW IS WE HAD ZERO INFLATION IN JULY, ZERO!!!” And the market bought it, and continued to run like Forrest Gump.

Day before FOMC minutes on 8/16 the market makes a recent peak of 431.73. Apple hit a new recent high of 176.15, being a mere $6.00 away from its all-time high!!!

8/17 and we get the latest FOMC minutes. Nothing to see here people, same old Fed talk, gonna fight inflation. Market thinks fed is going to go soft now that inflation is easing up (even though it’s really not) and maybe not even have to hike rates so much, some even think they might do an about-face and LOWER rates before the end of the year or early next year (HAHAHAHA!).

Market held up for one more day, then decided to cool off a little. Maybe it was the minutes, maybe it was just technical from going overbought on the daily RSI, maybe it was a little de-risking with the Jackson Hole conference coming up.

8/26 and we get Jerome Powell giving a now infamous 10 minute speech at the Jackson Hole conference with all the global central bankers. He re-iterates the feds commitment to bringing inflation down to 2% and that means continuing to RAISE RATES AND HOLD THEM THERE AS LONG AS NECESSARY to prevent inflation from becoming entrenched in our economy like what happened in the 70’s. One single month of CPI data was not nearly enough to convince the fed of a trend, he said it will take several months of clear data. The market finally got the hint, went oh shit J Pow means business and this is gonna suck Yong’s balls because supply is so tight and demand is still red hot. And SPY decided to shit $14.20 during market, and another $1.46 AH to end up at 403.85. Two solid weeks of the market running up in ignorance and stupidity, was wiped out in a single day.


So now that brings us up to today, 8/27, the day after. Where does the market go from here? That’s honestly a great question. On one hand, the market has a VERY short memory so it might find that secret stash of cocaine and decide next week we gonna party like an 80’s action flick and forget all our problems. On the other hand it seems maybe it’s gonna cool its jets a little with the realization the party is over, the pain train is coming, and people better buckle in cuz it’s gonna get bumpy.

Even Reuters is finally getting on board. One could argue that the Fed never changed their target rate or time-frame, I kept seeing the same info every FOMC minutes drop. I guess people just didn’t believe them. You can see in the chart below that the “fed funds futures contracts maturing through march 2024” are now taking into account a higher rate over a longer period of time. This is the smoking gun of why the market dropped yesterday, the market finally capitulated that the fed means business and the rate hikes and beatings will continue until morale improves!

Quite frankly, I still think this chart is still a smidge low and I believe the Fed is going to push 4% to maybe even 4.25% at its peak due to global conditions that will continue to keep energy & food supplies tight through 2023.

Why do I think that even this chart is underestimating necessary rates? First, BECAUSE I LISTEN TO WHAT THE FUCKING FED HAS BEEN SAYING FOR MONTHS! Take the tweet below. All the fed people have been talking a MINIMUM of 4% target, all have said they are going to diamondhand that rate through 2023 because if they don’t they KNOW inflation will simply reverse course and start coming back up. The chart above showing the futures traders still are not completely on board. I guess ignorance is bliss.

Fed Mester

Other reasons… first, crop yields are looking very challenging globally due to major drought and extreme heat conditions. The Russia/Ukraine was has already caused a shortage due to so many countries in that region dependent on Ukraine grain. The war has also sent fertilizer prices sky high, many farmers did not use as much fertilizer (or switched to other crops that didn’t need as much) which will further reduce yields on top of the drought conditions. If fertilizer and diesel prices are still sky high come planting season in 2023 we could see even higher food prices. I won’t even get into the conservation schemes some countries are trying to get their farmers to participate in instead of growing crops.

Second, energy supply & demand. We’ve recently seen that OPEC is still unable to meet recent quotas, but to add more insult to injury they are talking about CUTTING production to keep prices up if an Iran deal is made and their oil makes it to the market. “The impression remains that Saudi Arabia is not willing to tolerate any price slide below $90.” In the US, Biden’s emergency SPR release will also end on October 31st. Supplies in the US are obviously not where they need to be, and with Europe willing to pay a premium prices are going to be going up this winter.

I just noticed that Diesel prices went up over 20-cents in the past week here. I think gas prices jumped the same amount too.

Interesting Bloomberg Article: New York Fuel Supply Is So Low It Triggered White House Warning

The New York area is running so low on fuel that the Biden administration is warning of government action to address exports and suppliers are resorting to expensive US tankers to restock the region.

As US fuel demand soars, market forces alone may fulfill the Biden administration’s wish to curb exports. Domestic diesel consumption rises at this time of year, drawing down stockpiles, as Midwest farmers snap up supply to power machines that harvest crops. The approach of summer in South America, the largest overseas buyer of US diesel, means rising hydropower generation will potentially trim the region’s need for US fuel.

US East Coast

Europe’s energy prices have SKYROCKETED and with future uncertainty with Russia who knows where they can go. Check the chart below, not only are these energy prices unsustainable for residential consumers, businesses will be unable to operate and likely will be forced to shutdown!

Europe Bills

Okay, I think I’ve ranted enough and probably got a little off topic… So what’s the next big factors the market is bracing for?

September 13, 2022 - August CPI report
September 21, 2022 - Next Fed Rate Hike (50-75bps expected) & J Pow press conference

Some source data:

22 Likes

I love every bit of this write up, thanks for mapping out this timeline @TheMadBeaker. It appears that Macro is back on the table which ultimately means the old saying is still true, “dont fight the fed”.

It reminds me of an interview MacroAlf had on his podcast 3 or 4 months ago, Ill see if I can find it. He had a heavy hitting hedge fund strategist and trader on the show, when asked what her trades were for the remainder of the year she seemed a bit confused, she said that she was having a hard time wrapping her head around the fact that the fed wouldnt pivot. She was fairly young and its interesting to me to think how many young brilliant people are on Wall Street that have actually never seen this situation before in their careers. They have always had the fed step up and help the market in times of economic cooling or the few times the fed tried QT, they quickly reversed course, as mentioned in the original thesis.

This dislocation from the monetary policy / Macro reality is where I have seen and still see trading opportunities. I also think you pointed out a few areas that we should be thinking about as I think there should be some good plays there too, food and energy production. Both appear to be globally scarce and challenged heading into the near future.

Thanks again Beaker.

10 Likes

Oh god I love this… Bloomberg’s chart shows all countries will be back to 2% inflation by the end of 2023… HAHAHAHA!!!

‘Inflation Fever’ Is Finally Breaking — But Central Banks Won’t Stop Hiking Rates

As economic growth slows, prices for key raw materials — from oil to copper and wheat — have cooled in recent weeks, taking pressure off the cost of manufactured goods and food. And it’s getting cheaper to move those things around, as supply chains slowly recover from the pandemic.

After the worst price shock in decades, the speed at which relief arrives will vary, with Europe in particular still struggling. But for the world as a whole, analysts at JPMorgan Chase & Co. estimate that consumer-price inflation will fall to 5.1% in the second half of this year — roughly half of what it was in the six months through June.

Bloomberg Chart

7 Likes

Chart seems to predict US has already seen the worst of it. That would be nice.

2 Likes

Thanks @TheMadBeaker for breaking this down. I did not get to watch the speech on Friday. But have since read.

In my opinion this was the first time that JPow spoke with certainty in a long ass time. He sucked the hopium and jet fueled laced cocaine right out of the market.

However he did not say anything any of of us didn’t already know. Yes inflation is high yes rates will continue to go up. It is in fact also the first time he hasn’t puffed the chest and suggested how strong the US economy is and can withstand the rate increases.

Let us also keep in mind that currently we are sitting 2 months from a mid term election that can sway the path of the next two years of the political climate. I’d suspect that although the Fed is supposed to be apolitical they do face some moderate pressure from both sides of the aisle sending the economy into a recessionary climate is destructive.

I think the Friday sell off was reactionary and necessary I personally don’t think SPY should be at 450 but also don’t think it should be at 360. Currently the US is sitting in a position where demand is still quite elevated that’s why we have witnessed company after company post moderately decent ER even many besting their already elevated EPS.

As a lot of talk in the server we talk about not fighting the trend. For a month now we have been absent bad news and the market trends up. Now with the old reverse Friday. I think it’s realistically the opposite now. It takes some good news to turn the other direction. What that is I’m not sure. A significant drop in CPI coupled with a fed rate hike of .50 who knows. Should be some interesting months forthcoming.

Also wrong thread I posted this on. But works here too.

4 Likes

I think we should take a look at the CPI table and discuss which things we believe are going up / down / or staying flat.

Me personally, I’ve noticed that food prices have been steady or even ticking slightly up. (Though I realize this will vary regionally). Gas/Diesel prices also jumped 20-cents here in the last week out of the blue. We’ve seen both oil & gas prices going up due to Russia & Europe & global instability. I had to take my truck into the dealership for warranty work, and they had hardly any new vehicles on the lot, the chip shortage is still very much hampering production for all car companies. Apparel is likely falling due to people simply not buying unnecessary things. Shelter is still very much up there, at least for renters. I have a friend’s wife that works for a home builder in Houston and they’ve been having massive cancellations (much like TOL reported in recent earnings). For people wanting to build a new home they are requiring a substantial down payment so that they won’t lose money if they do cancel. He said previously like if you were building a 400k home you could put down 1k earnest money. Now they are requiring to put down 5% or more (so for a 400k home that would be 20k).

3 Likes

https://twitter.com/NorthmanTrader/status/1564307401041494016

A couple interesting articles this evening:

3 Likes

Just FYI, they posted the video of Brainard talking yesterday about the FedNow payment system. Of course this has nothing to do with current economic conditions.

Usually (not always) when a fed person speaks you can find the topic on the federal reserve calendar (or somewhere under the news section).

3 Likes

Wages are going to keep inflation high, and if not controlled soon, will spiral. With this many openings, wages have to go up.

4 Likes

Yea this is where its starts to get dodgy.
Wages have been behind inflation all year. Employees have been able to demand higher wages due to COL increasing and a tight labor market, not productivity, but now that revenue and earnings have started to feel the pain of inflation and a weakening economy, most companies wont be able to continue to raise wages, in fact the opposite where they will start cutting labor expenses.

At best people spend less and get by, at worst, defaults. Stagflation really is a brutal phenomenon because whenever household expenses and real wages dislocate it creates friction. The severity of this friction is yet to be seen.

5 Likes